This scam comes in several flavors, but the main ingredients never change.
The overpayment scam, also called the counterfeit check scam, is one of the most common and ever-evolving cons.
Typically, con artists find victims through classified ads and auctions, and offer them payment for anything from goods and services to rental deposits, jobs, vehicles and pets, according to the National White Collar Crime Center.
 |
| Counterfeit check scam |
 |
| |
| |
| Mystery shopping scam |
Bogus job offer
A Bankrate staff member’s father received a letter offering him a job as a mystery shopper. It turned out to be an overpayment scam with a job offer cover story.
The job? Cash a $4,985 check, keep $850 as compensation and wire the rest to a fake relative in Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. Allegedly, this would allow him to evaluate MoneyGram’s customer service in the process.
|
|
|
 |
Source: Bankrate.com |
|
|
|
| |
Do’s: |
|
Don’ts: |
| Insist on getting paid the correct amount. |
|
Assume a check is valid if it clears. |
| Report the scam. |
|
Rely on your own detective work to determine the check’s validity. |
| • |
Avoid doing business with anyone who insists you wire excess money elsewhere. |
|
• |
Deposit or cash checks if asked to wire some of the money elsewhere. |
|
|
|
The victim is given a counterfeit cashier’s check or money order for more than the cost of the advertised item and instructed to cash the check and send the extra money elsewhere, typically using a wire transfer service.
Reasons for the overpayment vary. Scammers may claim it was a mistake, that the excess cash is compensation for the inconvenience of cashing the check or that the money will go to a third party, such as a shipping company hired to transport the item.
Don’t believe the excuse provided.
“None of the explanations really make sense,” says Susan Grant, vice president for public policy and director of the National Consumers League’s Fraud Center. “Certainly they can send money directly to the person who’s doing the shipping.”
Scammers rely on a cushion of time, as it can take days or weeks before the victim’s bank discovers that the check is counterfeit.
“By that time, the victim has usually completed the transaction, wired the excess funds to the fraudster and is required to pay back the entire amount of the fraudulent check to the bank,” says April Wall, a research associate with the National White Collar Crime Center. “If this transaction involved the purchase of an item, then the victim is usually out of the item that they sold as well.”
According to the National Consumers League, the overpayment scam costs victims $3,000 to $4,000, on average. Victims also risk having their checking accounts closed by their banks and may experience difficulty opening accounts at other banks or credit unions, thanks to ChexSystems, a database that keeps tabs on people who mismanage checking and savings accounts.
A negative ChexSystems report stays in the database for five years and can hurt a person’s ability to open a checking account for that period.
Victims may even find themselves arrested for fraud if law enforcement authorities think they knew the check or money order was fraudulent.
“It may seem to the bank and/or police and prosecutors at least at first blush like they’re trying to pass a bad check,” says Grant.
Because consumers have so much to lose in this scheme, they have everything to gain from prevention.
Here are some common variations of the overpayment scam.
Job offer
How it works: A victim is contacted about an easy work-from-home job — processing checks for an employer’s customers or clients, which is usually foreign. As part of the job, employees are supposed to deduct their pay and then wire the rest of the money back to the employer.
If you take the job, however, you will lose any money you cash or deposit, plus any money you wire elsewhere.
Learn about a twist on the work-from-home scam involving a bogus mystery-shopping opportunity.
Classified ad
How it works: This is the classic form of the overpayment scam. A consumer takes out a classified ad or advertises an item and is then contacted by an interested buyer, who eventually sends a money order, cashier’s check or traveler’s check for much more than the cost of the item and asks the seller to wire the excess amount to someone else.
When the victim’s bank eventually discovers the check is fraudulent, it will hold the victim responsible for the amount. The victim will lose the money deposited or cashed at the bank, plus any funds wired elsewhere — and even the product, if the seller ships it before discovering the con.
Here’s one variation on the classified ad scam that at first caught a Spokane, Wash., resident off-guard.
Ginny Foster had advertised her Olde English Bulldogge puppies in several Washington state newspapers. One night she got a call from an operator who told her the caller would be using relay to communicate with her because he was hard of hearing. When the caller typed a message on his computer, the relay operator would read it to Foster.
The conversation was short — the con man gave her his e-mail address so that she could send him more information about the puppies.
Foster said it was his e-mail response that tipped her off, partly due to the terrible grammar, but also due to the nature of his request. In the e-mail, he told her he would send a certified Visa Traveler’s or cashier’s check, which she was to cash and then use the extra money to pay a shipping company that would come pick up the animal. Luckily, she knew not to send any money.
Foster said the relay call played to her sympathy because she thought the caller was hearing impaired. “If you let that clog your judgment, you’re screwed,” she says.
Roommate rip-off
How it works: The Internet Crime Complaint Center, or IC3, reports that one of the biggest current overpayment scams involves the use of legitimate rental housing and roommate-matching sites, such as Roommates.com. The scammer contacts people who have placed ads on the site looking for roommates and offers them the first month’s rent, the deposit or both in the form of a check or money order.
“Either one is conveniently more than the rent or deposit so the victim is asked to cash the said check or money order and send the difference either back to the would-be renter or to a ‘moving company’ — usually a second partner in the scam,” says Stacey Brown, an Internet fraud analyst with the IC3.
The cover story may vary, but the theme is the same: Scammers simply use fake money to entice you into sending real money. Get fooled by a phony roommate and you could lose some serious rent money. Brown estimates that victims lose $500 to $5,000, on average.
Being clever may cost you
Just because a check clears does not mean it’s a legitimate check. While federal law allows you to access the money within one to five days, depending on the type of money order or check, it can take weeks, or even months, for counterfeits to be discovered, says Grant.
Where to report a scam:
“There is no guarantee that that check won’t come back later,” she says.
Calling the bank on the check may not prove the check is real.
“Checks can be made to look as if they were drawn on actual businesses,” says Grant.
She says that the bank may tell you the company does have an account there or that there is enough in the account to cover the check. Only the business could tell you if they actually wrote the check.
Another problem with calling the bank is that it’s possible the fraudster made copies of a legitimate cashier’s check, she says.
As for checking with your bank, your bank basically advances the money to you before fully processing the check. Because your bank doesn’t know the original source of the check, you’re in the best position to know if it’s real — not the bank.
The best indication of a scam is the request to wire money somewhere. Because you’re sending money that is picked up as cash at the other end, it’s difficult to trace, and therefore favored by con artists.
“There is no legitimate reason why anyone who is paying you with a check or money order would ask you to wire money anywhere in return,” says Grant. She says it’s not a matter of waiting a certain number of days for the check to clear or trying to analyze the authenticity of the check or money order.
“If part of the deal is sending money somewhere else, that’s your confirmation that it’s a scam,” she says.
If you’ve wired money
“If they’ve realized it’s a scam before the bank contacts them, they should contact their bank immediately,” says Grant.
She advises contacting the money transfer service, too. If the other party hasn’t picked up the cash, then you may be able to get your money back. But usually it’s too late because the money is sent so quickly she says. If the cash has been collected, then it’s up to your bank to decide how to treat your dilemma.
source